Use “And” When They Say “But”

Reassurance and logic may not be the answer.

Many anxious kids get stuck in a loop of strong feelings and quick pushback, especially when something feels hard or uncertain.

As a parent, it is natural to respond with reassurance or logic, but those responses do not always help in the moment. When anxiety is high, kids are more focused on feeling safe than on hearing explanations. A small shift in how you respond can make it easier for your child to feel understood and still take a step forward.

This simple shift helps anxious kids move forward.

When your child is anxious, you’ll hear it quickly.

“But I can’t.”
“But it’s too hard.”

The instinct is to respond with logic or reassurance.

“But you can.”
“But it’s not that hard.”

That back-and-forth often keeps kids stuck. When anxiety is high, their brain is in threat mode. Freezing or pushing back is not defiance. It is a stress response.


Try This Instead: “And”

Replace “but” with “and.”

This allows two things to be true at once:

  • Your child’s feeling is real
  • They still need to move forward

Instead of correcting the feeling, you acknowledge it and gently guide the next step.


What It Sounds Like

Child:
“I can’t do my homework. It’s too overwhelming.”
Parent:
“I hear how overwhelming this feels and let’s take one small step to get started.”

Child:
“But I’m going to mess it up.”
Parent:
“That worry feels really strong and we can try the first part together.”


Keep the Step Small

What comes after “and” matters.

Anxiety shrinks when the task feels manageable. Breaking things into small, clear steps helps kids move from avoidance to action.

Think:

  • “Let’s open the laptop”
  • “Just write one sentence”
  • “We’ll try for two minutes”

If the step still feels too big, make it smaller.


Why This Works

“And” keeps connection intact while reducing power struggles.

You are not arguing or convincing. You are showing:
“I understand you and I believe you can do this.”

That combination builds momentum, and momentum helps reduce anxiety over time.


The Bottom Line

Your child’s “but” is anxiety talking.

When you respond with “and,” you validate the feeling while helping them take the next step forward.

About the Author

Stacy Santacroce, LCSW

Clinical Director

Over the last sixteen years, Stacy has worked with clients of all ages providing care for mental health and substance use disorders in outpatient, partial and intensive outpatient settings. Stacy maximizes the efficacy of cognitive-behavioral therapy using an individualized, strengths-based approach.